Products

Customize Your Batch of 5 Cookies

Approx. 2.5LBS of cookies!

Customize Your Batch of 10 Cookies

Approx. 5LBS of cookies!
12 products

12 products

Sold Out
Birthday Cake Remix
nycookiecow
$5.95
Sold Out
Chunky Monkey
nycookiecow
$5.95
Quick view
Midnight Moo Triple Chocolate
NY Cookie Cow
$5.50
Quick view
Midnight Peanut Butter Overload
NY Cookie Cow
$5.50
Quick view
Midnight Puff
nycookiecow
$5.95
Quick view
NY Chocolate Chip
NY Cookie Cow
$5.00
Quick view
NY Chocolate Chip Walnut
NY Cookie Cow
$5.50
Sold Out
Oatmeal Raisin Chock Full O' Oats
NY Cookie Cow
$5.25
Quick view
Oreo Faceplant
NY Cookie Cow
$5.95
Quick view
S'moo
NY Cookie Cow
$5.95
Midnight Moo Triple Chocolate
Midnight Moo Triple Chocolate
Midnight Moo Triple Chocolate
Midnight Moo Triple Chocolate
NY Cookie Cow

Midnight Moo Triple Chocolate

$5.50
/
A fantastically delicious and decadent cookie, these are not for the faint of heart. With plenty of cocoa powder and big wells of dark chocolate, these cookies are insanely soft, gooey and crazy delicious.
Midnight Peanut Butter Overload
Midnight Peanut Butter Overload
Midnight Peanut Butter Overload
Midnight Peanut Butter Overload
NY Cookie Cow

Midnight Peanut Butter Overload

$5.50
/
The perfect cookie for Chocolate Peanut Butter fanatics. Full of rich moist chocolate and studded with Reese’s butter cups and morsels, this cookie is a prized peanut butter chocolate sensation. These cookies will knock your socks off…we promise!
Midnight Puff
nycookiecow

Midnight Puff

$5.95
/
Big wells of dark chocolate from our Midnight Moo, stuffed with sweet marshmallow.
Mystery Cookie 1
NY Cookie Cow

Mystery Cookie 1

$6.25 $3.75 Save $2.50
/
Mystery Cookie 2
NY Cookie Cow

Mystery Cookie 2

$6.25 $3.75 Save $2.50
/
NY Chocolate Chip
NY Chocolate Chip
NY Chocolate Chip
NY Chocolate Chip
NY Cookie Cow

NY Chocolate Chip

$5.00
/

Our version of the classic chocolate chip cookie packed with semisweet morsels and Belgian milk chocolate chunks. Everything you know and love, but freshly baked with the finest ingredients! Slight crunch on the outside, gooey in the middle thickness, and melt in your mouth perfection.

NY Chocolate Chip Walnut
NY Chocolate Chip Walnut
NY Chocolate Chip Walnut
NY Chocolate Chip Walnut
NY Cookie Cow

NY Chocolate Chip Walnut

$5.50
/
The cookie that got us started – Our classic NY style chocolate chip walnut. A crisp outside with a warm, soft, & gooey inside. Loaded with couverture chocolate callets and chopped walnuts!
Oreo Faceplant
Oreo Faceplant
Oreo Faceplant
Oreo Faceplant
NY Cookie Cow

Oreo Faceplant

$5.95
/
A must-try if you love Oreo cookies. Sweet, rich, fluffy, with some chocolate chips, and loaded with crushed Oreo’s and vanilla crème filling. The most unbelievably creamy Oreo cookie of a lifetime.
S'moo
S'moo
S'moo
S'moo
NY Cookie Cow

S'moo

$5.95
/
Brown butter dough, chocolate chips, graham cracker crumbs and a gooey marshmallow center topped with a Hershey bar piece makes this cookie completely irresistible.The perfect way to get your s’mores fix without a campfire.